Commercial Arbitration or Court: Which Suits Your Dispute?
The route for resolving a dispute is usually decided when the contract is written, not when the disagreement arises. A practical comparison between arbitration and the commercial courts to help you choose.
Many commercial contracts end with a short clause on “dispute resolution” that the parties skim past. Yet that clause determines where you will stand if a dispute arises, how much it will cost you and how long it will take.
What is the difference?
The commercial courts: The Commercial Courts in the Kingdom have jurisdiction to hear commercial disputes under the Commercial Courts Law, and their procedures are now mostly electronic.
Arbitration: A private route in which the parties agree to refer their dispute to an arbitrator or arbitral tribunal of their choosing, which issues a binding award. It is governed by the Saudi Arbitration Law, which requires the arbitration agreement to be in writing.
A quick comparison
| Arbitration | Commercial Court | |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides | Arbitrators chosen by the parties, who may be specialists in the field of the dispute | The judges of the competent circuit |
| Confidentiality | Confidential as a rule | Hearings and judgments are public as a rule |
| Duration | A fixed period for issuing the award can be agreed | Depends on litigation procedures and the levels of appeal |
| Cost | Arbitrators’ fees and the centre’s charges, which may be high | Court costs are usually lower |
| Challenge | The award is final and may be challenged only by an action for annulment on specified grounds | Open to appeal and then, where applicable, cassation |
| Enforcement | Enforced once an enforcement order has been issued by the competent court | Enforced directly through the Enforcement Court |
When is arbitration the better fit?
- Complex technical disputes (construction, energy, technology) that call for an arbitrator with expertise in the field.
- Contracts with foreign parties, where an arbitral award is easier to enforce outside the Kingdom under the New York Convention.
- Where confidentiality matters to the company’s reputation or its trade secrets.
- High-value contracts that justify the cost of arbitration.
When is the court the better fit?
- Straightforward monetary claims and small or medium amounts, where the cost of arbitration outweighs its benefit.
- Where you need swift interim measures or need to join parties who are not party to the contract.
- Where you wish to keep the right of appeal.
Points to watch when drafting an arbitration clause
- Draft it clearly: a vague clause such as “the parties may resort to arbitration” opens a dispute over jurisdiction before the main dispute.
- Specify the centre and the rules: for example the Saudi Center for Commercial Arbitration (SCCA), or agree on ad hoc arbitration.
- Specify the number of arbitrators (an odd number), and the seat and language of the arbitration.
- Check the authority of the signatory: agreeing to arbitration requires special authorisation from the person entitled to dispose of the right.
In summary
No option is better in absolute terms. Arbitration gives you specialisation, confidentiality and finality at a higher cost; the court gives you lower cost and levels of appeal. The right decision is made when the contract is drafted, according to the nature and value of the transaction and the identity of the other party.
This article is for general awareness and does not constitute legal advice.
